Current weather

  • Overcast
  • 57°
  • Comment

Proposed halibut rule could change Homer's fishery

Posted: August 1, 2011 - 8:00am

A proposed federal rule changing how the charter catch share of Pacific halibut is allocated could dramatically change the Homer guided fishing business — and the jackpot halibut derby. Depending on the size of the total allowable halibut catch, local fishermen could see limits stay the same or reduced to one fish a day or two fish with one fish a limited size.

“The recently published halibut catch sharing plan (CSP) is an absolute disgrace,” said charter captain Rex Murphy, who has been following the issue. “It represents the outright theft of up to 30 percent of the existing guided recreational allocation by industry players who will profit from this action.”

A 45-day comment period opened last Thursday for the draft federal rule first recommended by the North Pacific Fishery Management Council and approved by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Fisheries Service, or NOAA Fisheries.

Under the former rule, put in place in 2003, charter fishermen were allocated a share of the allowable harvest, called a guideline harvest level. That gave charter fishermen a number of fish they could catch per day, but did not insure the overall catch stayed within a definitive limit, NOAA Fisheries said in a press release last week announcing the proposed rule.

Currently, charter anglers fishing out of Homer and other Cook Inlet ports in Area 3A are allowed two fish a day.

Southeast charter anglers in Area 2C are limited to one fish a day.

The catch sharing plan would give the charter fleet a set percentage of the overall allowable catch. Depending on how many millions of pounds of halibut the charter fleet receives, charter fishermen would be allowed one fish a day, two fish with one less fish than 32-inches long, or two fish. The allocations could be different for Area 2C, Southeast Alaska, and Area 3A, the central Gulf of Alaska including Cook Inlet and Homer.
The rule does not affect halibut caught by unguided sport fishermen or subsistence fishermen.

“The proposed catch sharing plan, which is scheduled to be in place by 2012, is designed to foster a sustainable fishery by preventing over harvesting of halibut and would introduce provisions that provide flexibility for charter and commercial fishermen,” NOAA Fisheries said in its release.

Commercial halibut is managed under the Individual Fishing Quota, or IFQ, program, with fishermen allowed to land so many pounds of halibut based on IFQs they received or purchased.

In a new twist, charter fishermen could lease for the season IFQs from commercial fishermen that would allow them to fish for a second fish, called a guided angler fish, if a one-fish limit was imposed.

The International Pacific Halibut Commission manages Pacific halibut under a joint agreement between the United States and Canada for halibut from California to the Bering Sea. At its annual meeting in January, the IPHC sets harvest levels. The U.S. Secretary of State and U.S. Secretary of Commerce then have to accept those catch limits.

After doing so, NOAA Fisheries publishes rules each year. The charter share is established before Feb. 1 each year to give charter captains and companies time to plan for the upcoming season.

In past years, the guideline harvest level for Area 3A charter fishermen has been 3.6 million pounds. Under a matrix developed for the new rule, the charter fleet would get varying percentages based on the combined fishery catch limit set by the IPHC. For example, with the 2009 catch limit of 21.7 million pounds, under the new rule the charter fleet would have received 3 million pounds, 600,000 less than the guideline harvest limit. Under that limit, guided fishermen would keep two fish, with one under 32 inches long.

In anticipation of the expected catch sharing plan, the Homer Chamber of Commerce Halibut Jackpot Derby Committee has been reviewing the derby and exploring new ideas. That work won’t be done until the fall, and no ideas have yet been presented to the chamber board.

Currently, the big, five-figure cash prize of the derby goes to the angler with a derby ticket who catches the biggest halibut during the derby season. Other prizes are awarded for each month’s biggest fish, the biggest fish caught monthly by a woman and for tagged fish. Murphy’s calculations show under one scenario the charter fishery loses 1 million pounds, a 30-percent reduction.

“Everybody recognizes this is something we need to prepare for,” said Homer Chamber of Commerce Executive Director Monte Davis. “If it is what it is, we have to figure out how to make it work.”

Davis said he’s talking to NOAA Fisheries about sending a representative to Homer to explain the catch sharing plan at a community meeting. No time or date has been set, but Davis said he hopes to have a meeting by Aug. 14.

  • Comment

Comments (4) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
JOAT 08/01/11 - 10:40 am
Halibut protection needed

Anything that reins in our out-of-control "commercial" guides/charters sounds good to me. The guides have already destroyed the Kenai River. Let's put the binders on them before they also destroy our halibut fisheries.

That halibut derby in Homer is the next thing that needs to go or get a serious facelift. Luring people in on a gamble to go out and target the biggest, breeding female halibut is going to kill the halibut fishery just as fast as all the giant king harvests of the 80's and 90's have done to the Kenai.

If there are any responsible managers down there in Homer, you guys need to stop the "big fish wins" concept immediately. Change the entire derby over to a random weight under 70# lottery. Here's how you fix the derby AND get more participation: The day before the derby opens, have a big ceremony and randomly select a sealed and secret weight from a pool that contains every weight to the tenth pound from 30# to 70#. Think sealed envelopes in a tumbler basket. That sealed weight is then locked up in a vault at the derby headquarters for the duration of the derby.

Now, people go out and catch fish in the 30 to 70 pound range. Any fish over 70# isn't going to win (which are all breeding females), so it gets released. The first 1 or 2 fish between 30-70# are kept. They are weighed and that person gets their derby entries for the official weight, rounded to 1/10 pound. You may get a number of people with the same weight. Like the Nenana ice classic, whatever weight wins, the pot splits between all entries. If no one hits the exact weight, you work down to the next closest lower weight.

At the end of the derby, you hold a huge event/picnic/party whatever for the official opening of the vault and the winning weight envelope. As the grand finale, the envelope is opened with much anticipation (and live media coverage, just think of all the press, Homer) to reveal the winning weight class. The winners listed in the class are quickly pointed out to much cheering and merriment. Everyone is happy and we are leaving all those breeding females out in the ocean to continue laying up to 4-million eggs each winter.

Yeah, think about that for a minute. Each fisherman that keeps a 300-pound barndoor halibut just removed 4,000,000 baby halibut from the ocean, compounded every year for the next 20, 25, 30 or more years that fish would have lived.

spybot 08/02/11 - 10:23 am
Joat - Great idea for all

Seeing as how commercial IFQ holders harvest 80% of the overall catch - your idea should be also expanded to them as well - after all it is a catch share plan - and what is good for one side of the plan should be good for the other side also.

No retention by anyone, charter or commercial, for halibut over 75 pounds - let the big butts go!

Great idea Joat!

BigRedDog 12/06/11 - 06:54 am
Mushy halibut syndrome

All this talk about shares and size, and nobody has said a word about the one thing that could really be killing our Halibut fishery. So keep on trucking with that MY Share mentality and everyone will be in for a shock when a disease comes in and takes it's share! What is this mushy halibut syndrome and what percent of our young halibut are suffering from it and will they survive? Should we throw them back or remove an ill fish from the gene pool? There are some very hard questions that nobody is answering whose impact have the capacity to change the whole ballgame! Is somebody at NOAA with the answer as to what portion of the halibut have MHS and what will become of those fish?

stuartw13 01/02/12 - 12:30 am
Back to Top


Please Note: You may have disabled JavaScript and/or CSS. Although this news content will be accessible, certain functionality is unavailable.

Skip to News

« back

next »

  • title
  • title
  • title
My Gallery


  • 150 Trading Bay Rd, Kenai, AK 99611
  • Switchboard: 907-283-7551
  • Circulation and Delivery: 907-283-3584
  • Newsroom Fax: 907-283-3299
  • Business Fax: 907-283-3299
  • Accounts Receivable: 907-335-1257
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback