Current weather

  • Broken clouds
  • 61°
    Broken clouds
  • Comment

Giessel defeats Arness in Senate District N

Posted: August 29, 2012 - 8:44am  |  Updated: August 29, 2012 - 9:54am

At least 50 people walked into the Nikiski Senior Center around 5 p.m. Tuesday and many said they were confused by what they saw on their ballot after casting their votes in the primary election. 

They entered the ballot booth believing they’d be voting between incumbent Sen. Tom Wagoner and challenger Peter Micciche and were instead asked to pick between incumbent Cathy Giessel and challenger Joe Arness. 

The trouble revolved around Senate District N, a newly formed legislative district which covers the northern portions of the Kenai Peninsula including Nikiski, Sterling, Cooper Landing and the eastern portion, from Hope to Seward, as well as Turnagain Arm and south Anchorage. 

Nikiski is no longer part of the same district as neighboring Kenai and Soldotna and some voters expressed dismay at the geographic diversity of their new district. 

“The demographic style between south Anchorage and here is so vastly different,” said Lindsay Cooper. “How will she be able to represent both when south Anchorage has a much different demographic? The industry is different, the population is different.”

That thought is something Giessel said she was hoping to combat as she continues her re-election campaign against Ron Devon, an Independent challenger who is also from Anchorage. 

“That’s why I’m here on the Peninsula three to four days a week, travelling,” she said. “I don’t go home at night because it is so critical that I’m there in person meeting people and hearing the needs of the area and understanding just the geography and the community, all of that. I understand that it’s a big piece of geography and I understand the responsibility of knowing the issues and knowing the people.”

Giessel said her opponent’s lack of visibility on the Kenai Peninsula was part of the reason he lost the primary. 

“At the end of the day, this is applying for a job and if you were an employer and somebody sent in a  letter to apply for a job but never took the time to interview with you personally, how would you feel?,” she said. 

As she did often on the campaign trail, Giessel called the portion of Anchorage that she represented “rural” and said it shared many issues with other residents of the Kenai Peninsula. 

“There’s on-site water and wastewater treatment,” she said. “We share a lot of the same employers in oil and gas, tourism, mining, fishing. It’s not really south Anchorage and people frame it as south Anchorage. It’s not the Dimond Mall. It’s the hillside and Turnagain Arm. These are the rural parts of Anchorage.”

Devon, Giessel’s new opponent, said he’d been hearing people on the Kenai Peninsula say they weren’t happy with the idea of representation from Anchorage. His solution has also been to travel the Peninsula and communicate with residents. 

“There’s quite a diversity in our district,” Devon said. “I’ve lived in a lot of rural and urban settings in the state, I think I have a unique perspective in a lot of areas. For me, it’s a lot of getting to know folks in different areas and I resonate with people pretty well.”

With all precincts reporting, Giessel carried nearly 65 percent of the vote while Arness had just over 35 percent. 

Arness, who spent the evening at his cabin in Nikiski, said he was honored that so many people had voted for him. 

“I feel badly that I didn’t prevail, but on the other hand $60,000 versus $4,000, what do you expect,” he said. “I did what I could.”

 Editors note: This article was changed after a quote was misattributed to Cathy Giessel when it should have been attributed to Ron Devon. 

Rashah McChesney can be reached at

  • Comment

Comments (5) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
santini 08/29/12 - 01:29 pm
Giessel Defeats Arness in Senate District N

Mr. Arness lost to Senator Giessel simply because she totally out campaigned him. Sure, there is a widely disparate demographics in the newly formed District N. Instead of bemoaning the fact, Senator Giessel rolled up her sleeves got got to know her new constitutes. She did this by spending a lot of time in the new southern part of the district. She attended many public meetings on the Peninsula in which local issues were discussed. The amount of spending in a campaign doesn't necessarily translate into support. Hard work and fresh ideas go a long to compensate for scarce campaign resources. The ability to get others to support and work for your campaign also says a lot about the candidate. Senator Giessel earned her victory by earning each vote one at a time.

jake 09/01/12 - 08:43 am
wonder how the vote was split

wonder how the vote was split, how many local votes for the local guy vs. how many Anchorage votes for the Anchorage girl?

Allen 09/04/12 - 12:46 pm
Good questions

According to the Division of Elections, Senate District N is House District 27 (South Anchorage) where Kathy Giessl is the incumbent and House District 28 which is the new "donut" district for the north Peninsula. House 27 has twice as many Republican votes as House 28. The donut district has always been a gift to South Anchorage Republicans like Cathy Geissl. It is well hated by north Peninsula residents since they get ignored by the Senator except for right before an election, and a north Peninsula candidate doesn't have a chance of winning against an Anchorage candidate.

And as expected, incumbent Cathy Geissl had 2078 votes to 680 votes for Joe Arness in House 27. Joe would have had to win just about every vote in House 28 to win.

So Cathy Geissl meet Jerry Ward. Well at least Cathy hasn't bought a trailer in Nikiski yet. Or has she?

Allen 09/04/12 - 12:57 pm

Sorry I meant Cathy with a C Geiss-e-l. And House 28 includes the east Peninsula not just the north.

spybot 09/05/12 - 01:43 pm
Joe Arness didn't campaign - not too difficult to beat

When you don't actively campaign, it is difficult to beat your opponent.

Joe Arness had few if any campaign signs, ads or mailers, and was a no show at most community events this summer where all others seeking public office were in attendance.

Cathy Giessel outcampaigned Joe Arness plain and simple. She showed up at just about every conceivable campaign appearance, spoke to people about her views and vision of government, and listened to the cares and concerns of constituents in the new district.

When you put little skin or show leather in the game, it is tough to claim your opponent had an unfair advantage.

The comparison of Cathy Giessel to Jerry Ward is uncalled for and demeaning.The best thing Tom Wagoner did was beat Jerry Ward.

By the way, Giessel took 9 out of 10 precincts in District 28, including Nikiski, home town to Arness.

Back to Top


Please Note: You may have disabled JavaScript and/or CSS. Although this news content will be accessible, certain functionality is unavailable.

Skip to News

« back

next »

  • title
  • title
  • title
My Gallery


  • 150 Trading Bay Rd, Kenai, AK 99611
  • Switchboard: 907-283-7551
  • Circulation and Delivery: 907-283-3584
  • Newsroom Fax: 907-283-3299
  • Business Fax: 907-283-3299
  • Accounts Receivable: 907-335-1257
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback