Archer disputes Buccaneer claims, files suit

Buccaneer Energy-Kenai Offshore Ventures and Archer Drilling last Thursday ended their relationship for Archer to operate the $100 million Endeavour-Spirit of Independence jack-up rig. The rig has been in the Homer Harbor since arriving last August, missing a late-summer and early fall drilling window and racking up a large bill in harbor fees.


Buccaneer said it fired Archer. On Wednesday, officials with Archer visiting Homer said that’s not true — Archer terminated its contract with Buccaneer on Dec. 13.

“We actually terminated it first,” said David Walker, quality, health, safety and environment manager with Archer in Houston.

Also on Wednesday, Archer filed a $6 million lawsuit in Texas District Court, Houston, seeking payment for what it says are past-due bills for services and expenses.

Jay Morakis of JMR Worldwide, Buccaneer’s public relations office, said Buccaneer officials decided to sever ties with Archer Drilling Company on Friday, Dec. 14, after hearing the company was not paying local subcontractors for work on the rig and for “non-performance.”

Archer says all its vendor relationships are current and it is not delinquent in payments to vendors or employees, Walker said. Walker said he could not speak to any payments owed by Buccaneer to vendors or employees not affiliated with Archer.

Walker and other officials met with Homer City Manager Walt Wrede, Homer Harbormaster Bryan Hawkins and U.S. Coast Guard officials on Wednesday to tell them their side of the issue and relay their concerns.

Walker said Archer had almost terminated its relationship with Buccaneer twice before, most recently in October, and made its decision after it sent a letter of intent to Buccaneer outlining issues, including unpaid bills. When Buccaneer executives failed to show up at a meeting in Houston, that’s when Archer pulled the plug.

“After a year of experiencing delays in getting paid and witnessing shortages in scopes of work for the refurbishment of the Endeavour, Archer in its experience believes those conditions had not been met and cannot agree to crew and operate the Endeavour in its current conditions and under its current ownership,” Archer said in its lawsuit.

Morakis said Buccaneer is aware of the lawsuit.

“We are currently reviewing the suit and believe that the allegations are entirely without merit. We look forward to responding to them in a court of law, as well as asserting our damage claims in this matter,” he said.

Buccaneer is a partner with, and the manager of Kenai Offshore Ventures — a joint venture project that owns the Endeavour with Ezion Holdings and the Alaska Industrial Development and Export Authority. Morakis said Buccaneer acted in the best interest of the partnership.

“The issue is for work performance between KOV and Archer,” he said.

Morakis said the dispute should not “in any way impede the timeline of the rig at all.”

Work on the Endeavour is mostly complete, Buccaneer said in a press release Monday. Archer had been working on upgrades and repairs of the jack-up rig, including correcting work done in the Keppel Fels shipyard in Singapore, Dean Gallegos, director of Buccaneer Energy Limited, said in Monday’s press release.

Walker said Archer was hired to operate and manage the drilling operations. He said Archer told Buccaneer the Endeavour was not ready to leave Singapore when it left.

“The Defendants turned a blind eye to the amount of time, money and effort needed to bring such a rig up to operational levels,” Archer’s lawsuit asserts.

The lawsuit alleges that work needed to be done before coming to Alaska included installation of mud treatment and conditioning systems, refurbishment of deep well riser systems and winterization of exposed working areas.

Crews have been working on the Endeavour since its arrival in August.

Buccaneer said an inspection by the American Bureau of Shipping last week showed one minor door replacement and some paperwork requirements, Gallegos said. After ABS confirms completion of that work, Buccaneer will proceed with a U.S. Coast Guard inspection. Buccaneer also is waiting on issuance of a land-use permit by the Alaska Department of Natural Resources to move the Endeavour to the Cosmopolitan oil and gas permit site offshore of Anchor Point. The move is anticipated to be sometime in January, Gallegos said.

On Friday afternoon Morakis said Kenai Offshore Ventures had entered into a letter of intent with Spartan Offshore Drilling to take over operating the Endeavour.

Representatives of Spartan and Buccaneer will meet in Homer on Monday to implement the handover of rig management duties. Spartan’s experience in Cook Inlet will benefit Buccaneer, Gallegos said.

Archer Drilling will work with Spartan to make the handover, Walker said.

“This will not be lock the doors, throw the keys and say good-bye,” he said.

In a statement last Friday, Karsten Rodvik, AIDEA Spokesman, wrote that the group was aware of the situation and that its “first concern and main priority is for Alaska workers and businesses to be promptly paid.”

Initial rumors that Archer had first walked away from the rig because they could not pay their local contractors as a result of a billing dispute with Buccaneer did “not surprise” Morakis, he said.

However, Morakis said KOV and Buccaneer consider themselves “paid in full” to Archer “with the exception of some disputed amounts for work that has been done.” Morakis could not provide details on that debt.

Buccaneer will work to make sure Homer-based contractors and others who worked on the rig who are owed money by Archer are paid for their services, Morakis said.

Homer Port Director and Harbormaster Bryan Hawkins said he watched an exodus of workers loading up and leaving the rig, which he described as “a little bit depressing and definitely concerning.”

Hawkins said Archer called to inform him they were pulling workers off the rig because they “no longer have a contract” with Buccaneer. However, when Hawkins asked for details, Archer wouldn’t elaborate, he said.

“There is still a skeleton crew on board making sure that the rig is safe and warm making sure we don’t have any damage due to the freezing conditions and things like that,” he said.

Hawkins estimated about 50 construction workers, pipefitters, welders and other contractors were employed on the rig. He said he hoped they would be put back to work — likely many of those same people who left — sooner rather than later.

“There’s only so many qualified people,” he said with a laugh.

Homer City Manager Walt Wrede said the announcement got the city’s attention and prompted a Friday morning teleconference with Buccaneer officials. Wrede said he had initial concerns about the status of those rig workers and who would be left to look after a giant piece of infrastructure the city had no way of moving otherwise.

“They seemed very, very motivated to make sure all the contractors got paid,” he said.

Buccaneer isn’t current with its payments to the city, Wrede said. However, the city is not concerned that it won’t get paid, he added. Hawkins said the city bills harbor users monthly, from the 15th of the month to the 15th.

“Buccaneer has been paying us. They’ve sent us some pretty large checks recently,” Wrede said. “We are confident they are going to pay.”

Morakis said that according to the last bill Buccaneer received from the city and dated Dec. 15, Buccaneer owed $103,521.72. He said Buccaneer has paid its bills through Dec. 6.

Wrede said he came away from the conference feeling it was just a “short term shake-up.” He said the rig’s prolonged presence had not turned away any commerce at the port and that the city was, for the most part, happy for the additional business it has brought in.

“It is usually a slow time of year here in Homer so it was good to have hotels filled and restaurants filled and people getting a paycheck,” he said.

Wrede said he encouraged Buccaneer officials to get busy drilling for gas in light of recent news of looming area shortages. Hawkins echoed a similar sentiment.

“The reality is that we have a rig and it is right there and all of us have an interest in seeing that it is successful in its venture, which is to bring more gas online,” Hawkins said. “Sometimes I find that some things just come harder than others. I don’t know why, but they just do.

In other news regarding the Endeavour, Buccaneer said in its latest press release that:

■ It anticipates DNR will approve its plan of operations in mid January. The comment period ended Dec. 3 on that application.

■ Buccaneer has applied for a gas-only determination for the Cosmo project with the Alaska Oil and Gas Conservation Commission. Gallegos said it understands the commission has made a gas-only recommendation to the Alaska Department of Environmental Commission, but Buccaneer has not heard from DEC.

■ A revised contingency plan, or C-Plan, for the Cosmo site has been filed. Buccaneer received a C-Plan for its Southern Cross and North West Cook Inlet projects, and has filed a revised plan for Cosmo based on that C-Plan. Public comments for that revised C-Plan are due Dec. 28.


Brian Smith can be reached at Michael Armstrong of the Homer News contributed to this article. He can be reached at