Court sets high bar on states’ campaign contribution limits

  • By MATT VOLZ
  • Tuesday, May 26, 2015 11:20pm
  • News

HELENA, Mont. (AP) — States may cap political donors’ campaign contributions only if they can show that those limits are preventing corruption or the appearance of corruption, a federal appeals court ruled Tuesday.

The ruling, which affects the nine states under the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, uses the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2010 Citizens United decision to raise the bar for states to justify limiting campaign donations in state elections.

States can limit contributions if they have a legitimate interest in doing so. But proving that state interest has changed since the Citizens United decision that said corporations can spend unlimited amounts in elections, a three-judge panel for the 9th Circuit said in its ruling.

Before the Citizens United decision, states only had to show they aimed to curb the influence of big money on politicians. After Citizens United, states must show more specifically that their laws are stopping an exchange of money for political favors, the opinion written by Judge Carlos Bea said.

“Now, the prevention of quid pro quo corruption, or its appearance, is the only sufficiently important state interest to justify limits on campaign contribution,” Bea wrote.

The ruling was made in a case that challenged Montana’s contribution limits as violating donors’ rights to free speech and association. The other states in the court circuit with contribution limits are Alaska, Arizona, California, Hawaii, Idaho, Nevada and Washington.

Oregon is the only state of the nine that has no limits on campaign contributions.

The attorney for the plaintiffs in that case, James Bopp, said the ruling is significant and creates a high bar for states to keep their contribution limits.

“The issue is a very new issue. This is the first decision of its kind,” Bopp said.

U.S. District Judge Charles Lovell of Helena used the pre-Citizens United standard in determining there was a state interest for Montana’s campaign-contribution limits. The judge ultimately found the limits were unconstitutional for a different reason: they are too low for candidates to effectively campaign.

The appeals court reversed Lovell and sent the case back the judge with orders to apply the post-Citizens United standard. It said the judge must decide whether the state attorney general’s office has proven its argument that contribution limits further the state’s interest and to identify what that interest is.

The 9th Circuit’s decision means Lovell must carefully measure whether the limits are fair to donors, candidates and the citizens who want fair and equal status in their elections, Montana Commissioner of Political Practices Jonathan Motl said.

Montana’s individual contribution limits are $170 for legislative candidates, $320 for attorney general candidates and $650 for gubernatorial candidates.

The law also sets total contribution limits from political party committees to candidates that range from $850 per election for a state House candidate to $23,350 for a gubernatorial candidate.

Lovell struck down the contribution limits a few weeks before the 2012 election. The 9th Circuit blocked the ruling just days after the state filed an appeal, but not before the Montana Republican Party used Lovell’s ruling to donate $500,000 to former U.S. Rep. Rick Hill’s gubernatorial campaign and $32,000 for Tim Fox’s campaign for attorney general.

Fox returned the money after the 9th Circuit blocked the ruling, but Hill did not.

More in News

Montessori materials sit on shelves in a classroom at Soldotna Montessori Charter School on Tuesday, Sept. 20, 2022 in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Education debate draws state attention to peninsula charter schools

Dunleavy would like to see a shift of authority over charter school approvals from local school districts to the state

The Nikiski Senior Center stands under sunlight in Nikiski, Alaska, on Thursday, March 14, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Support available for community caregivers

Nikiski Senior Center hosts relaunched Kenai Peninsula Family Caregiver Support Program

Flags flank the entrance to Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s office on Thursday, March 14, 2024, in Juneau, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Dunleavy vetoes bipartisan education bill

Senate Bill 140 passed the House by a vote of 38-2 and the Senate by a vote of 18-1 last month

The Alaska State Capitol on Friday, March 1, 2024, in Juneau, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
House passes bill altering wording of sex crimes against children

The bill is sponsored by Rep. Sarah Vance, R-Homer

Ben Meyer and Brandon Drzazgowski present to the Soldotna and Kenai Chambers of Commerce at the Soldotna Regional Sports Complex in Soldotna, Alaska, on Wednesday, March 13, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai Watershed Forum gives update on streambank restoration

The watershed forum and other organizations are working to repair habitat and mitigate erosion

The entrance to the Kenai Police Department, as seen in Kenai, Alaska, on April 1, 2020. (Photo by Brian Mazurek/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai resident arrested on charges of arson

Kenai Police and Kenai Fire Department responded to a structure fire near Mountain View Elementary

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, R-Nikiski, speaks in opposition to an executive order that would abolish the Board of Certified Direct-Entry Midwives during a joint legislative session on Tuesday, March 12, 2024 in Juneau, Alaska. (Ashlyn O'Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Legislature kills most of Dunleavy’s executive orders in rare joint session

All the proposed orders would have shuffled or eliminated the responsibilities of various state boards

Nikiski Middle/High School student Maggie Grenier testifies in favor of a base student allocation increase before the Alaska Senate Education Committee on Monday, Feb. 12, 2024, in Juneau, Alaska. (Screenshot)
Students report mixed responses from lawmakers in education discussions

Delegates from the Kenai Peninsula Borough School District lobbied the Alaska Legislature for more state funding and other education priorities

A child waves from the back of a truck as the 32nd annual Sweeney’s St. Patrick’s Day Parade proceeds down Fireweed Street in Soldotna, Alaska on Friday, March 17, 2023. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
St. Patrick’s Day parade set for Sunday

The annual Sweeney’s St. Patrick’s Day Parade, hosted by the Soldotna Chamber of Commerce, kicks off at 2 p.m.

Most Read