What others say: Too many laws

This is an example of government overreach.

 

Sitka’s government has outlawed children in businesses that allow smoking, whether anyone is smoking at the time or not.

No exceptions.

This clarifies a 2005 law banning smoking in public places. Fine, it’s OK for local government to choose to be smoke-free.

But, private businesses should be able to choose whether to be smoke-free or not, and parents should decide whether their children are allowed to enter those businesses.

The main Sitka event affected by the clarification is the American Legion Christmas party — a once-a-year celebration for children, and a smoke-free one at that.

It simply means that the Legion cannot host the party unless it becomes a smoke-free facility. It doesn’t sound like it will change its smoking policy.

Does this type of rule really help anybody, including the little people?

Their exposure to a room once a year that allows smoking when they’re not there isn’t dangerous — at least not as dangerous as them walking home from school or riding down the street in a motor vehicle. Their health is probably more vulnerable in an airplane, being on a playground, playing sports or any other number of circumstances children have every day.

What would the kids say? “Don’t be a spoiled sport.”

— Ketchikan Daily News,

April 14

More

Op-ed: The McConnell nonrescue

It was the end of 2012. The country was courting fiscal and political disaster. The Obama-administration Democrats were at an impasse with the adamant GOP... Read more

Op-ed: Porking out with your money

Citizens Against Government Waste (CAGW), a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization working to eliminate governmental waste and fraud, just released its “2017 Congressional Pig Book,” an annual... Read more

Editorial: Who pays for services?

We all expect a certain level of service from government — good schools, well maintained roads, fully staffed first responder agencies, for example — but... Read more

Op-ed: The looming Republican disgrace

The ascension of Donald Trump was supposed to change everything in the GOP. As it happens, perhaps one very important thing hasn’t: The Republicans may... Read more