Polls: Americans often sympathize with union position

Posted: Sunday, September 02, 2001

WASHINGTON Americans have grown more sympathetic to unions over the past couple of years in labor-business disputes, but the public is divided on whether the unions should have more power, according to an Associated Press poll.

As Labor Day 2001 approaches, the public generally sides with the unions in disputes by a 2-to-1 margin, 50 percent to 27 percent, according to the poll conducted for the AP by ICR of Media, Pa. The poll comes at a time of economic uncertainty and job layoffs.

Respondents favored unions over companies in labor disputes by a much smaller margin less than 10 percentage points two years ago when the economy was booming.

I used to feel sorry for the companies because I thought a lot of the unions were asking too much, said Ted Sklany, a retired lab technician in Charlottesville, Va. But the bottom line is that workers are usually getting the short end of the stick.

His support can depend on the issues in question, but he said, If a union is striking for better benefits, Im for them.

Young adults were more likely to side with the unions than people over 65, and those in the Northeast and Midwest were more likely than people in the South and West. Republicans were split, Democrats sided with unions 3-to-1, and independents backed unions by 2-to-1.

Besides any effects of the slumping economy, the tilt toward unions comes at a time when organized labor is in more of an underdog role with Republicans controlling the White House.

General approval for unions runs nearly 3-to-1, roughly the same as in recent years, but higher than 20 years ago when it was less than 2-to-1.

Workers who have gone on strike in recent years include nurses at hospitals from Massachusetts to Minnesota, pilots at Comair, baggage handlers at United Airlines in Denver and workers at Verizon and The Seattle Times.

While public sentiment for the unions is on the rise, union membership is not.

The percentage of American workers belonging to unions fell last year to 13.5 percent, the lowest in six decades, according to the Labor Department. Union officials have blamed a decline in heavily unionized industries, accompanied by job growth in nonunion parts of the economy.

Union jobs in the private sector have declined in the fast-changing economy, a trend the unions have tried to counter by attempting to organize in occupations that dont require hard hats, such as home health care workers or even doctors.

In the new poll, four in 10 people said unions were now at about the right strength, twice the number who thought they were too strong. The poll of 1,010 people was taken from Aug. 22 through Sunday and had an error margin of plus or minus 3 percentage points.

An AP poll in 1989 indicated that a third of people thought unions were too strong, about the same number that said they were powerful enough.

Michael Morrison, 24, of Gainesville, Fla., is one of those who thinks unions are about the right strength, adding: It seems like a good equilibrium.

When people talk about unions being too powerful, they sometimes refer to political activism.

Noting the efforts and money spent by the unions in the most recent presidential election, Linda Schaenzer, a 47-year-old government employee from Nashua, N.H., said: I would be appalled as a union member if my dues were spent that way.

People were about evenly split on whether they think unions will get stronger or weaker.

I do believe they will continue to get weaker, said 36-year-old union shipyard worker Cliffton Crisswell of Mobile, Ala. The big companies want them out, the unions are less vocal now and they dont push their issues.

But like many others, Jenny Tower, 18, of Roswell, N.M., thinks tough economic times will help build support for unions. A lot of people keep losing their jobs.

AP Labor Writer Leigh Strope contributed to this story.

Subscribe to Peninsula Clarion

Trending this week:


© 2018. All Rights Reserved. | Contact Us