It is what it is: The great debate

There are some things I’m hesitant to discuss with people I’ve just met — religion and politics are probably near the top of the list.

People tend to have very strongly held views on those topics, and until you get to know them, you run the risk of getting into an argument over some casual remark that wasn’t intended to offend. When people whom I’ve just met bring those topics up, I try to listen politely and move on to another topic, usually with a Forrest Gump response — something factual but noncommittal, followed with “and that’s all I have to say about that.”

After this summer, I think I’m ready to put sports on that list, too.

I’ll admit, I used to be a passionate sports fan. I could recite stats and debate starting lineups with the best of them. Of course, at that time, let’s just say there weren’t a lot of championship parades going on where I grew up, and most of my sports arguments ended that way, too. It’s pretty hard to come up with a rebuttal when the team on the other side of the debate has a championship ring.

While I still follow sports, over the past few years I have become a much more casual fan. It’s a fun diversion, but a topic I no longer lose sleep over (except maybe when my team is in the World Series).

Anyway, this past summer, my wife and I spent a few days at a lodge in Maine to do some mountain biking. I had a blast, but there was a point one evening where the chit chat with other guests turned from topics I am comfortable with — careers, raising kids, mountain biking adventures and getting older — to sports. And then it got downright uncomfortable when the topic of sports intersected with politics.

Apparently, there are some East Coast states where mercy rules for high school football have been taken to extremes, and coaches are suspended for exceeding certain point totals and point differentials. Now, I never played organized football, but I did play soccer and run track through college. I also coached a high school soccer team for a few seasons, and I have been on both sides of a lopsided game. To be honest, neither side is a whole lot of fun, but I’ve always felt that taking your lumps is one of those things that builds character. And over my athletic career, I’d say I built a lot of character.

Anyway, let’s just say the debate was passionate but unmoderated, and some of the participants had very strong personalities. Making it more interesting — and from my perspective, uncomfortable — was that one of the participants had played in the NFL, but only a few people in the room knew it. It was, as the kids say, awkward. I pointed out that when I covered sports, I was glad to see Alaska use a running clock in the second half when games got out of hand — but that’s all I had to say about that.

After what felt like forever, and with the debate still going strong, I yawned, stretched and headed off to bed. Fortunately, the discussion didn’t carry over to the next day, and we talked about the virtues of bacon and maple syrup over breakfast. We all whole-heartedly endorsed those things as delicious.

However, as an Alaskan, there are certain questions that are bound to come up when you travel, and I will say this about the intense debate on high school football: it made the inquiries that we got regarding Sarah Palin look pretty tame — and that’s all I have to say about that.

Reach Clarion editor Will Morrow at will.morrow@peninsulaclarion.com.

More in Life

File
Minister’s Message: Being a person of integrity and truth

Integrity and truth telling are at the core of Christian living.

Photo by Christina Whiting
Selections from the 2025 Lit Lineup are lined up on a shelf at the Homer Public Library on Friday, Jan. 3.
A new Lit Lineup

Homer Public Library’s annual Lit Lineup encourages year-round reading.

Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion
A copy of “The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood is Causing an Epidemic of Mental Illness” rests on a desk in the Peninsula Clarion newsroom in Kenai, Alaska, on Tuesday, Jan. 7, 2025.
Off the Shelf: ‘Anxious Generation’ underserves conversations about cellphones

The book has been cited in recent school board discussions over cellphone policies.

Nellie Dee “Jean” Crabb as a young woman. (Public photo from ancestry.com)
Mostly separate lives: The union and disunion of Nellie and Keith — Part 1

It was an auspicious start, full of good cheer and optimism.

This hearty and warm split pea soup uses bacon instead of ham or can be made vegan. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
Hearty split pea soup warms frigid January days

This soup is nutritious and mild and a perfect way to show yourself some kindness.

These savory dumplings are delicious steamed, boiled, deep fried, or pan fried and are excellent in soups or added to a bowl of ramen. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
Facing the new year one dumpling at a time

I completed another impossibly huge task this weekend and made hundreds of wontons by hand to serve our large family

”Window to the Soul” by Bryan Olds is displayed as part of “Kinetic” at the Kenai Art Center in Kenai, Alaska, on Tuesday, Dec. 31, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Movement on display

Kenai Art Center’s January show, ‘Kinetic,’ opens Friday

Virginia Walters (Courtesy photo)
Life in the Pedestrian Lane: More of the same?

I have no particular expectations for the New Year

Mitch Gyde drowned not far from this cabin, known as the Cliff House, on upper Tustumena Lake in September 1975. (Photo courtesy of the Fair Family Collection)
The 2 most deadly years — Part 8

The two most deadly years for people on or near Tustumena Lake were 1965 and 1975

Most Read