Chief justice defends judicial nominating process

The governor said there were qualified applicants “inexplicably” not nominated

  • By BECKY BOHRER Associated Press
  • Monday, March 25, 2019 11:54pm
  • News

JUNEAU — Founders of the state’s constitution intended for a governor to appoint for judgeships candidates nominated by the Alaska Judicial Council, the chief justice of the Alaska Supreme Court said.

Chief Justice Joel Bolger, in recent remarks, defended the council’s process for vetting and nominating candidates after Gov. Mike Dunleavy filled one vacancy on the Palmer Superior Court but refused to fill another.

One of the seats is vacant. The second is soon to be.

Dunleavy, in a letter to the council last week, said he would not be making a second appointment from a list of three finalists the council sent him. He said there were qualified applicants “inexplicably” not nominated and requested the council’s reasoning.

Dunleavy spokesman Matt Shuckerow said the governor looks forward to scheduling a meeting with Bolger to further discuss the matter.

The council’s website shows there were 13 applicants for the two seats but two withdrew and a third was appointed to another judgeship.

Under the constitution, the governor is to fill a superior court vacancy by appointing one of two or more persons nominated by the council. The Alaska Supreme Court has held the council is within its right to send one more nominee than the number of positions to be filled.

State law calls for a governor to fill a superior court vacancy or appoint a successor for an impending vacancy within 45 days after receiving nominations from the council. That period has passed.

Susanne DiPietro, the council’s executive director, said the seven-member council plans to meet Thursday to discuss its options. She did not get into what those might be.

She said former Govs. Wally Hickel and Frank Murkowski pushed back on nominations but filled seats within 45 days.

Bolger’s comments were posted on the commission’s website. DiPietro said they were made at the start of a commission meeting Friday.

Bolger said the council, on which he serves, aims to nominate the most qualified candidates. He said areas considered include professional competence, fairness, temperament, legal and life experience and commitment to public and community service.

Each council member votes independently, Bolger said. If a candidate receives four votes, his or her name is forwarded to the governor, he said.

It is not uncommon for the council to nominate a person for one position but not for another, Bolger said. Strength of the other candidates, the nature of the open position and the community the judge will serve are considerations, he said.

Democratic Rep. Matt Claman of Anchorage said Friday that Dunleavy “is failing to uphold the constitution” in the matter and has failed to follow the rule of law.

Shuckerow said by email Monday that Claman “should join the Governor in asking for more openness and transparency in this process adopted by the Judicial Council.”

Claman scrapped a Friday hearing on one of Dunleavy’s crime bills after speaking about the judicial matter and what Claman said was a denial by the governor’s office of a travel request by the state public defender. Claman said travel for public defender Quinlan Steiner was denied for the remainder of session.

Given that, Claman said he would only hear Anchorage-based staff with the administration testifying on crime bills by phone until travel for Steiner is approved.

Steiner said he was denied travel for a criminal justice commission meeting this month that ultimately wound up being paid for by the commission and for hearings on crime legislation and the Public Defender Agency’s budget last week.

He said he was at one point asked to submit a travel plan, then was told by a deputy commissioner in the Department of Administration, under which his agency falls, that Dunleavy’s chief of staff denied travel for the rest of session then on Friday was asked for a travel plan that he said he will submit.

Steiner said he is trying to make a case for additional funding because his agency has more cases than it can handle and without more money could have to start refusing cases, which he said would disrupt the criminal justice system. Being at hearings in person also can be advantageous in weighing in on bills and helping resolve any potential snags, he said.

Dunleavy’s office has said it wants to end nonessential travel, and Shuckerow said previously that the Office of Public Advocacy and the Public Defender Agency have said they are underfunded.

The governor’s office “has approved certain travel in the past, but is currently requesting a formal travel plan for the remainder of the legislative session to consider what is within reason,” Shuckerow said.

He said if committee chairs prefer testimony by phone, “that is perfectly acceptable to the Administration.”


• By BECKY BOHRER, Associated Press


More in News

State House District 6 candidates Rep. Sarah Vance, Dawson Slaughter and Brent Johnson participate in a candidate forum hosted by the Peninsula Clarion and KBBI 890 AM at the Homer Public Library in Homer, Alaska, on Tuesday, Oct. 29, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Saturday update: House District 6 race tightens slightly in new results

Neither incumbent Rep. Sarah Vance or challenger Brent Johnson have claimed 50% of votes in the race

A grader moves down 1st Avenue in Kenai, Alaska, during a snow storm on Tuesday, Feb. 28, 2023. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Storm system to bring weekend snow to western Kenai Peninsula

Extended periods of light to moderate snow are expected Friday through Sunday morning

Homer Electric Association Chief Operating Officer Rob Montgomery speaks during a joint luncheon of the Kenai and Soldotna Chambers of Commerce at the Kenai Chamber of Commerce and Visitor Center in Kenai, Alaska, on Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
HEA talks search for new energy sources, hazard trees at chamber luncheon

The utility produces 90% of its electricity using natural gas

Alaska State Troopers logo.
Update: Troopers arrest Anchor Point man wanted on felony warrants

Troopers sought help from the public in a search for Tanner Allen Geiser

From left: Joseph Miller Jr. and Jason Woodruff, Alaska State Troopers charged with felony first-degree assault, appear with their lawyers, Clinton Campion and Matthew Widmer, for an arraignment at the Kenai Courthouse in Kenai, Alaska, on Thursday, Nov. 14, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Troopers renew not guilty pleas after grand jury indictment

Woodruff, Miller charged with felony first-degree assault for alleged conduct during May arrest in Kenai

Canna Get Happy owner Sandra Millhouse, left, appears with attorney Richard Moses during a meeting of the Board of Adjustment at Kenai City Hall in Kenai, Alaska, on Oct. 15, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai board of adjustment denies Canna Get Happy appeal

The owner sought to operate a retail marijuana establishment at Swanson Square in Kenai

A winter weather advisory and special weather statement are in effect for the western Kenai Peninsula, while other messages are published for the eastern Kenai Peninsula, in this map from the National Weather Service. (Screenshot/National Weather Service)
Snowfall, heavy winds forecast for tonight

Winter weather advisory and other messages from National Weather Service effective through Friday morning

The storefront of Madly Krafty in Kenai, Alaska, is seen on Thursday, Nov. 14, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Soldotna Chamber of Commerce holds 5th annual Spark event

Soldotna sharks give $4,000 scholarship to local gift shop

Kenai Peninsula Borough School District Superintendent Clayton Holland speaks during a meeting of the KPBSD Board of Education in Soldotna, Alaska, on Monday, June 3, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
School board considers ‘hypothetical’ 4-day calendar, asks for community survey

Included in the work session notes is a potential calendar describing weeks running from Monday to Thursday starting in August 2025

Most Read