Larry Persily (Juneau Empire file photo)

Larry Persily (Juneau Empire file photo)

Opinion: State’s ‘what if’ lawsuit doesn’t much add up

The state’s latest legal endeavor came July 2 in a dubious lawsuit — with a few errors and omissions for poor measure

  • By Larry Persily
  • Friday, July 12, 2024 1:30am
  • Opinion

The state of Alaska, with all the legal wisdom of a political agenda and the flowing words of a high-priced law firm, has filed a claim against the federal government. Nothing new about that — the state has filed and signed onto more lawsuits against the national government in recent years than President Joe Biden has forgotten dates or former President Donald Trump has told lies.

Nothing to be proud of in any of that.

The state’s latest legal endeavor came July 2 in a dubious lawsuit — with a few errors and omissions for poor measure — that asks $25 billion to compensate the state for what it could have, might have, possibly may have earned as its share of federal royalties from potential oil production in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge.

The Biden administration canceled the federal oil and gas leases in ANWR more than three years ago, much to the disgust of Gov. Mike Dunleavy and many Alaskans who have long complained that overly restrictive federal oversight has denied the state its rights to resource development.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

The state already is in court to establish the validity of those leases, but all a win in that case would provide is the opportunity for someone to spend billions of dollars to explore for oil and gas on the contested acreage. Maybe make some money, but maybe lose a lot of money. A lot of exploration efforts come up empty.

This latest claim is much more lucrative than that: If the state wins, it gets a big check. No investment risk, no environmental impact statement to attract opponents, no worry about unsuccessful exploration and drilling, no carbon emissions. Just cash for the state treasury.

Yet the state’s claim to lost billions is a bit of a scam: It’s based on the unrealistic premise that everything is certain in oil development.

The $25 billion math assumes billions of barrels of oil are there, securely trapped between rock layers, just waiting for a drill rig to find the sweet spot to stick a straw in the ground and start pumping. If it were that easy, and guaranteed, everyone would invest in oil. But it’s not. Oil isn’t always where explorers think it is, and it doesn’t always flow to the surface as predicted.

The state’s claim is calculated on the best possible outcome of multiple “what ifs,” conjuring up the highest possible number. It’s not honest or realistic, but that doesn’t really matter when you’re just trying to score a political point that federal policy is holding back Alaska’s future.

However, there are no ifs about the errors in the lawsuit, such as the statement that the trans-Alaska oil pipeline is half full. Wrong. It is less than one-quarter full. Doesn’t anyone proofread these things before running to file in court and make the news?

The lawsuit got it right when it said Alaska has no personal income tax, and therefore is dependent on oil and gas revenues help pay for schools, roads, health care services, rural development and “care for its Alaska Native communities.” But it failed to mention that the single largest appropriation of state spending in this year’s budget is to send hefty Permanent Fund dividends to Alaskans.

Maybe the lawyers figured the state would gain more sympathy from the court if it pleads it needs the money to care for Native communities rather than to keep paying the dividend.

I hope the state didn’t pay the lawyers too much. This lawsuit is a gusher of politics, not reality.

Larry Persily is the publisher of the Wrangell Sentinel.

More in Opinion

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, R-Nikiski, speaks at a town hall meeting in the Moose Pass Sportsman’s Club in Moose Pass, Alaska, on Friday, Feb. 28, 2025. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Rep. Justin Ruffridge speaks during a town hall meeting hosted by three Kenai Peninsula legislators in the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly Chambers in Soldotna, Alaska, on Saturday, March 29, 2025. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Capitol Corner: HB 161 — Supporting small businesses

Rep. Justin Ruffridge reports back from Juneau.

The Swan Lake Fire can be seen from above on Monday, Aug. 26, 2019, on the Kenai Peninsula, Alaska. (Photo courtesy Alaska Wildland Fire Information)
Point of View: Fire season starts before Iditarod ends

It is critical that Alaskans exercise caution with anything that could ignite a fire.

The U.S. Capitol in Washington, March 25, 2025. (Eric Lee/The New York Times)
Point of View: Wake up America

The number one problem in America is our national debt resulting from the inability to control federal spending.

Snow collects near the entrance to the Kenai Community Library on Thursday, March 10, 2022, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Libraries defend every American’s freedom to read

Authors Against Book Bans invites you to celebrate National Library Week.

Rep. Justin Ruffridge, R-Soldotna, speaks during a town hall meeting hosted by three Kenai Peninsula legislators in the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly Chambers in Soldotna, Alaska, on Saturday, March 29, 2025. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Capitol Corner: Preparing for wildfire season

Rep. Justin Ruffridge reports back from Juneau.

Alaska State House District 7 Rep. Justin Ruffridge participates in the Peninsula Clarion and KDLL 91.9 FM candidate forum at the Soldotna Public Library on Monday, Oct. 14, 2024, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
Capitol Corner: Putting patients first

Rep. Justin Ruffridge reports back from Juneau.

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, R-Nikiski, speaks at a town hall meeting in the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly Chambers in Soldotna, Alaska, on Saturday, March 1, 2025. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Capitol Corner: Building better lives for Alaskans

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman reports back from Juneau.

Gov. Mike Dunleavy compares Alaska to Mississippi data on poverty, per-pupil education spending, and the 2024 National Assessment of Education Progress fourth grade reading scores during a press conference on Jan. 31, 2025. Alaska is highlighted in yellow, while Mississippi is in red. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire)
Opinion: Freeing states from the ‘stranglehold’ of the U.S. Department of Education

The USDOE has also been captured by a political ideology that has been harmful to education in America.

Alaska State House District 7 candidate Rep. Justin Ruffridge participates in the Peninsula Clarion and KDLL 91.9 FM candidate forum at the Soldotna Public Library on Monday, Oct. 14, 2024, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
Capitol Corner: Building a culture of reading

Rep. Justin Ruffridge reports back from Juneau.